Institutional Policies E-Book

INTRODUCTION

From 100 Case Studies to a Policy Manual

This Policy Manual did not begin as a legal project. It began as a research question.

For many years, the work of The Hswagata Buddha Tooth Relics Preservation Museum and The Office of Siridantamahapalaka brought the author into contact with many different situations of relic custodianship: peaceful shrines and conflictual ones, well-managed museums and chaotic storerooms, generous donors and questionable ones, careful monks and careless committees. Some of these situations ended in harmony, others in dispute, loss or harm.

To understand these patterns in a disciplined way, the author undertook a systematic study of 100 cases connected to relics, institutions and governance – the Hswagata 100 Case Studies. These cases were analysed using a scientific and qualitative research approach:

careful observation of real institutions and events,

structured interviews, conversations and document review,

comparison across countries and contexts,

and coding of patterns related to ethics, peace, law and organisational behaviour.

The goal was not to collect stories for curiosity, but to ask:

“What makes a relic institution safe, ethical and peaceful – and what makes it fragile, unjust or violent?”

What the 100 Case Studies Revealed

Across the 100 cases, certain repeating causes of problems became visible:

lack of clear policies for donations, relic custody and decision-making;

confusion about roles and responsibilities between monks, lay committees, state officials and donors;

absence of safeguarding rules for children, women and vulnerable people;

no written standards for financial integrity, data protection or anti-corruption;

weak or non-existent systems for complaints, conflict resolution and learning;

relics and sacred objects treated as private property rather than trust property held for the Saṅgha and the wider community.

The research also found positive patterns: places where written guidelines, clear procedures and shared ethical commitments helped prevent conflict and protect both people and relics. From these positive cases emerged the model of the H96 custodian – a custodian who is:

ethically disciplined (Vinaya-based),

non-greedy and transparent,

respectful of law and human dignity,

committed to peace and institutional harmony,

and open to accountability and oversight.

Why Policy First, Constitution Later

During and after the research, the author recognised a practical sequence:

Many institutions wanted a Constitution or set of founding statutes.

But without clear policies for daily practice, a Constitution alone could not prevent the problems seen in the 100 cases.

A Constitution typically defines high-level structure and authority, but it rarely answers detailed questions such as:

How are safeguarding incidents handled step by step?

How are relics catalogued and secured?

How is donor money checked and reported?

How are complaints and conflicts managed in a peaceful way?

The conclusion was simple but important:

Before designing a lasting Constitution, an institution needs a working Policy Manual that has been tested in real practice.

The Policy Manual becomes a kind of living laboratory:

It translates Vinaya, law and research findings into concrete rules and procedures.

It allows staff, volunteers and monastics to try out ethical and governance standards in everyday work.

It reveals what works, what needs adaptation and what gaps remain.

Only after such policies have been applied, evaluated and refined over time does it become wise to write or revise the formal Constitution of the institute, so that the Constitution:

reflects actual, tested practice, not only theory;

incorporates the best elements of the H96 custodian model;

and has a realistic chance of being followed.

For this reason, the author decided that the first step for The Hswagata Buddha Tooth Relics Preservation Museum should be a comprehensive Policy Manual, grounded in the Hswagata 100 Case Studies and aligned with Vinaya, Myanmar law and UNESCO standards. A future Constitution or Charter of the institution can then grow from this base.

Purpose and Scope of This Manual

This Manual therefore has four main purposes:

To translate the lessons of the Hswagata 100 Case Studies into practical policies for governance, relic custodianship, safeguarding, finance, HR, communications, environment and data protection.

To operationalise the H96 custodian model, providing clear expectations and tools for all custodians, staff, volunteers and monastics in Hswagata institutions.

To align institutional practice with Theravāda Buddhist ethics, Myanmar law and relevant international and UNESCO frameworks.

To prepare the ground for a future Constitution or founding statutes of the Museum and related bodies, based on tested and refined policies.

The Manual is not intended to be a theoretical book. It is a working document: it must be read, used, questioned and improved. Each section connects directly to real problems and real solutions found in the Hswagata 100 Case Studies.

For Whom is This Manual Written?

This Manual is written for:

The Office of Siridantamahapalaka and those directly involved in relic custodianship;

staff and volunteers of The Hswagata Buddha Tooth Relics Preservation Museum;

monastics taking on official institutional roles;

Board or advisory members, including Saṅgha and lay representatives;

and, indirectly, other temples, museums, NGOs and authorities interested in ethical relic and heritage governance.

A Living Document

Finally, this Manual is understood as a living document. As more cases arise and more experience is gained, the policies will:

be monitored through risk registers and institutional peace indicators,

be evaluated and adjusted,

and eventually inform the writing or revision of a formal Constitution and other foundational documents for the institution.

In this way, the circle is complete:

Research (Hswagata 100 Case Studies) leads to

Policy (this Manual), which shapes

Practice, which produces new

learning for future Constitutional and legal development.

The chapters that follow set out the framework for that journey.

NOT FOR SALE!